| Vinyl Dilla Construction Loop Sets 24 ACID WAV | |||
| Loop Set 1 Mix 88 Dm.wav | 20.99 MB | ||
| Loop Set 10 Mix 92 Dm.wav | 13.66 MB | ||
| Loop Set 10a 92 bpm Dm Intro | |||
| 10a Intro Guitar 92 Dm.wav | 1.33 MB | ||
| Loop Set 10b 92 bpm Dm Main | |||
| 10b Air 92.wav | 1.32 MB | ||
| 10b Bass 92 Dm.wav | 1.32 MB | ||
| 10b Bell Tree 92.wav | 678.65 KB | ||
| 10b Crowd 92.wav | 2.64 MB | ||
| 10b Guitar 92 Dm.wav | 2.64 MB | ||
| 10b Hat 92.wav | 2.64 MB | ||
| 10b Kick 92.wav | 2.64 MB | ||
| 10b Shaker 92.wav | 1.32 MB | ||
| 10b Snaps 92.wav | 2.64 MB | ||
| 10b Snare 92.wav | 2.64 MB | ||
| 10b Triangle 92.wav | 1.32 MB | ||
| 10b Window 92 Dm.wav | 1.32 MB | ||
| Loop Set 1a 88 bpm Dm Intro | |||
| 01a Bass 88 Dm.wav | 716.72 KB | ||
| 01a Cowbell 88 Dm.wav | 356.68 KB | ||
| 01a Hat 88.wav | 709.29 KB | ||
| 01a Keys 88 Dm.wav | 1.38 MB | ||
| 01a Keys Filter 88 Dm.wav | 1.39 MB | ||
| 01a Kick 88.wav | 709.29 KB | ||
| 01a Snare 88.wav | 709.29 KB | ||
| 01a Wurli 88 Dm.wav | 1.38 MB | ||
| Loop Set 1b 88 bpm Dm Chorus | |||
| 01b Bass 88 Dm.wav | 2.76 MB | ||
| 01b Clap 1 88.wav | 1.38 MB | ||
| 01b Clap 2 88.wav | 1.38 MB | ||
| 01b Cowbell 88 Dm.wav | 1.38 MB | ||
| 01b Hat 88.wav | 2.76 MB | ||
| 01b Keys 88 Dm.wav | 5.52 MB | ||
| 01b Keys Filter 88 Dm.wav | 5.52 MB | ||
| 01b Kick v.wav | 1.38 MB | ||
| 01b Piano 88 Dm.wav | 5.51 MB | ||
| 01b Pipe 88 Dm.wav | 2.76 MB | ||
| 01b Snare 88.wav | 2.76 MB | ||
| 01b Wurli 88 Dm.wav | 5.51 MB | ||
| Loop Set 1c 88 bpm Dm Verse | |||
| 01c Bass 88 Dm.wav | 2.76 MB | ||
| 01c Clap 1 88.wav | 2.76 MB | ||
| 01c Clap 2 88.wav | 1.38 MB | ||
| 01c Cowbell 88 Dm.wav | 1.38 MB | ||
| 01c Hat 88.wav | 2.76 MB | ||
| 01c Keys 88 Dm.wav | 5.52 MB | ||
| 01c Keys Filter 88 Dm.wav | 5.52 MB | ||
| 01c Kick 88.wav | 2.76 MB | ||
| 01c Piano 88 Dm.wav | 2.76 MB | ||
| 01c Snare 88.wav | 2.76 MB | ||
| 01c Wurli 88 Dm.wav | 5.51 MB | ||
| Loop Set 2 Mix 95 F.wav | 16.42 MB | ||
| Loop Set 2a 95 bpm F Intro | |||
| 02a Electric Piano 1 95 F.wav | 1.28 MB | ||
| 02a Electric Piano 2 95 F.wav | 1.28 MB | ||
| 02a Hat 95.wav | 657.36 KB | ||
| 02a Kick 95.wav | 657.36 KB | ||
| 02a Snare 95.wav | 657.46 KB | ||
| Loop Set 2b 95 bpm F Chorus | |||
| 02b Bass 95 F.wav | 2.56 MB | ||
| 02b Electric Piano 1 95 F.wav | 5.11 MB | ||
| 02b Electric Piano 2 95 F.wav | 5.11 MB | ||
| 02b Hat 95.wav | 2.56 MB | ||
| 02b Kick 95.wav | 2.56 MB | ||
| 02b Pipes 95 F.wav | 5.11 MB | ||
| 02b Snap 1 95.wav | 1.28 MB | ||
| 02b Snap 2 95.wav | 1.28 MB | ||
| 02b Snare 95.wav | 2.56 MB | ||
| 02b Synth 95 F.wav | 5.11 MB | ||
| Loop Set 2c 95 bpm F Verse | |||
| 02c Bass 95 F.wav | 2.63 MB | ||
| 02c Electric Piano 1 95 F.wav | 5.1 MB | ||
| 02c Electric Piano 2 95 F.wav | 5.1 MB | ||
| 02c Hat 95.wav | 2.63 MB | ||
| 02c Kick 95.wav | 2.63 MB | ||
| 02c Snap 1 95.wav | 2.63 MB | ||
| 02c Snap 2 95.wav | 2.63 MB | ||
| 02c Snare 95.wav | 2.63 MB | ||
| Loop Set 3 93 bpm A | |||
| 03 Clap 93.wav | 1.31 MB | ||
| 03 Conga 93.wav | 1.31 MB | ||
| 03 Kick 93.wav | 1.31 MB | ||
| 03 Organ 93 A.wav | 2.61 MB | ||
| 03 Ride 93.wav | 2.61 MB | ||
| 03 Shaker 93.wav | 1.31 MB | ||
| 03 Sub 93 A.wav | 1.31 MB | ||
| 03 Sweep 93.wav | 5.22 MB | ||
| 03 Vocal 1 93.wav | 2.61 MB | ||
| Loop Set 3 Mix 93 A.wav | 22.3 MB | ||
| Loop Set 4 Mix 90 Bb.wav | 21.53 MB | ||
| Loop Set 4a 90 bpm Bb | |||
| 04a Bass 90 Bb.wav | 2.7 MB | ||
| 04a Hat 90.wav | 2.7 MB | ||
| 04a Kick 90.wav | 2.7 MB | ||
| 04a Pizzicado 90 Bb.wav | 1.35 MB | ||
| 04a Rhodes 90 Bb.wav | 5.39 MB | ||
| 04a Snare 1 90.wav | 1.35 MB | ||
| 04a Snare 2 90.wav | 1.35 MB | ||
| 04a Strings 90 Bb.wav | 5.39 MB | ||
| Loop Set 5 Mix 85 Abm.wav | 24.89 MB | ||
| Loop Set 5a 85 bpm Abm Intro | |||
| 05a Guitar 85 Abm.wav | 1.44 MB | ||
| 05a Guitar Pluck 85 Abm.wav | 369.21 KB | ||
| 05a Hatter 85 Abm.wav | 1.43 MB | ||
| 05a Kick 1 85.wav | 369.12 KB | ||
| 05a Kick 2 85.wav | 369.12 KB | ||
| 05a Snare 1 85.wav | 734.16 KB | ||
| 05a Snare 2 85.wav | 734.16 KB | ||
| Loop Set 5b 85 bpm Abm Main | |||
| 05a Bass Buzz 85 Abm.wav | 1.43 MB | ||
| 05a Electric Piano 85 Abm.wav | 5.71 MB | ||
| 05a Guitar 85 Abm.wav | 5.71 MB | ||
| 05a Guitar Pluck 85 Abm.wav | 734.66 KB | ||
| 05a Hat 85.wav | 1.43 MB | ||
| 05a Hatter 85.wav | 5.71 MB | ||
| 05a Kick 1 85.wav | 734.16 KB | ||
| 05a Kick 2 85.wav | 2.86 MB | ||
| 05a Rhodes 85 Abm.wav | 5.71 MB | ||
| 05a Snare 1 85.wav | 1.43 MB | ||
| 05a Snare 2 85.wav | 1.43 MB | ||
| Loop Set 6 86 bpm C | |||
| 06 Bass 86 C.wav | 2.82 MB | ||
| 06 FX 86.wav | 725.46 KB | ||
| 06 Hat 86.wav | 1.41 MB | ||
| 06 Kick 86.wav | 1.41 MB | ||
| 06 Pad 86 C.wav | 5.64 MB | ||
| 06 Rhodes 1 86 C.wav | 5.64 MB | ||
| 06 Rhodes 2 86 C.wav | 5.64 MB | ||
| 06 Snare 86.wav | 1.41 MB | ||
| 06 Snare Back 86.wav | 1.41 MB | ||
| Loop Set 6 Mix 86 C.wav | 23.24 MB | ||
| Loop Set 7 96 bpm Cm | |||
| 07 Bass 96 Cm.wav | 2.54 MB | ||
| 07 Clap 96.wav | 2.53 MB | ||
| 07 Flute 96 Cm.wav | 2.53 MB | ||
| 07 Hat 96.wav | 1.27 MB | ||
| 07 Kick 1 96.wav | 1.27 MB | ||
| 07 Kick 2 96.wav | 1.27 MB | ||
| 07 Rhodes 96 Cm.wav | 5.06 MB | ||
| 07 Snare 1 96.wav | 2.53 MB | ||
| 07 Snare 2 96.wav | 2.53 MB | ||
| 07 Strings 96 Cm.wav | 5.05 MB | ||
| Loop Set 7 Mix 96 Cm.wav | 10.73 MB | ||
| Loop Set 8 95bpm Cm | |||
| 08 Bass 95 Cm.wav | 2.56 MB | ||
| 08 Chorus Rhodes 95 Cm.wav | 5.11 MB | ||
| 08 Clap 95.wav | 2.56 MB | ||
| 08 Drummer 95.wav | 2.56 MB | ||
| 08 Hat 95.wav | 1.28 MB | ||
| 08 Kick 95.wav | 1.28 MB | ||
| 08 Piano 95 Cm.wav | 2.55 MB | ||
| 08 Rhodes 95 Cm.wav | 5.11 MB | ||
| 08 Rim 95.wav | 2.56 MB | ||
| 08 Snap 95.wav | 2.56 MB | ||
| Loop Set 8 Mix 95 Cm.wav | 10.2 MB | ||
| Loop Set 9 Mix 93 Bbm.wav | 11.72 MB | ||
| Loop Set 9a 93 bpm Bbm Intro | |||
| 09a Scratch 93.wav | 337.83 KB | ||
| 09a Voices 93 Bbm.wav | 1.31 MB | ||
| Loop Set 9b 93 bpm Bbm Main | |||
| 09b Bass 93 Bbm.wav | 2.61 MB | ||
| 09b Glide 93 Bbm.wav | 671.46 KB | ||
| 09b Hat Single Hit 93 Bbm.wav | 1.31 MB | ||
| 09b Hat Triplet 93.wav | 1.31 MB | ||
| 09b Keys 93 Bbm.wav | 2.61 MB | ||
| 09b Kick 93.wav | 2.61 MB | ||
| 09b Shake 93.wav | 1.31 MB | ||
| 09b Snap 93.wav | 1.31 MB | ||
| 09b Snare 93.wav | 1.31 MB | ||
| 09b Strings 93 Bbm.wav | 2.61 MB | ||
| 09b Voices 93 Bbm.wav | 5.22 MB | ||
| Vinyl Dilla Loop Sets README.pdf | 266.89 KB | ||
| Vinyl Dilla Construction Loop Sets REX2 | |||
| Loop Set 1 Mix 88 Dm.rx2 | 14.49 MB | ||
| Loop Set 10 Mix 92 Dm.rx2 | 8 MB | ||
| Loop Set 10a 92 bpm Dm Intro | |||
| 10a Intro Guitar 92 Dm.rx2 | 813.31 KB | ||
| Loop Set 10b 92 bpm Dm Main | |||
| 10b Air 92.rx2 | 730.46 KB | ||
| 10b Bass 92 Dm.rx2 | 649.76 KB | ||
| 10b Bell Tree 92.rx2 | 383.76 KB | ||
| 10b Crowd 92.rx2 | 2.12 MB | ||
| 10b Guitar 92 Dm.rx2 | 1.44 MB | ||
| 10b Hat 92.rx2 | 1.52 MB | ||
| 10b Kick 92.rx2 | 1.28 MB | ||
| 10b Shaker 92.rx2 | 634.62 KB | ||
| 10b Snaps 92.rx2 | 1.29 MB | ||
| 10b Snare 92.rx2 | 1.24 MB | ||
| 10b Triangle 92.rx2 | 654.45 KB | ||
| 10b Window 92 Dm.rx2 | 720.08 KB | ||
| Loop Set 1a 88 bpm Dm Intro | |||
| 01a Bass 88 Dm.rx2 | 368.87 KB | ||
| 01a Cowbell 88 Dm.rx2 | 172.6 KB | ||
| 01a Hat 88.rx2 | 184.93 KB | ||
| 01a Keys 88 Dm.rx2 | 716.21 KB | ||
| 01a Keys Filter 88 Dm.rx2 | 811.8 KB | ||
| 01a Kick 88.rx2 | 287.24 KB | ||
| 01a Snare 88.rx2 | 348.79 KB | ||
| 01a Wurli 88 Dm.rx2 | 670.72 KB | ||
| Loop Set 1b 88 bpm Dm Chorus | |||
| 01b Bass 88 Dm.rx2 | 1.39 MB | ||
| 01b Clap 1 88.rx2 | 315.53 KB | ||
| 01b Clap 2 88.rx2 | 164.47 KB | ||
| 01b Cowbell 88 Dm.rx2 | 695.25 KB | ||
| 01b Hat 88.rx2 | 647.42 KB | ||
| 01b Keys 88 Dm.rx2 | 2.77 MB | ||
| 01b Keys Filter 88 Dm.rx2 | 3.12 MB | ||
| 01b Kick v.rx2 | 352.61 KB | ||
| 01b Piano 88 Dm.rx2 | 1.72 MB | ||
| 01b Pipe 88 Dm.rx2 | 845.43 KB | ||
| 01b Snare 88.rx2 | 1.07 MB | ||
| 01b Wurli 88 Dm.rx2 | 2.56 MB | ||
| Loop Set 1c 88 bpm Dm Verse | |||
| 01c Bass 88 Dm.rx2 | 1.37 MB | ||
| 01c Clap 1 88.rx2 | 667.26 KB | ||
| 01c Clap 2 88.rx2 | 164.39 KB | ||
| 01c Cowbell 88 Dm.rx2 | 695.25 KB | ||
| 01c Hat 88.rx2 | 647.42 KB | ||
| 01c Keys 88 Dm.rx2 | 2.78 MB | ||
| 01c Keys Filter 88 Dm.rx2 | 3.13 MB | ||
| 01c Kick 88.rx2 | 704.79 KB | ||
| 01c Piano 88 Dm.rx2 | 647.05 KB | ||
| 01c Snare 88.rx2 | 1.07 MB | ||
| 01c Wurli 88 Dm.rx2 | 2.55 MB | ||
| Loop Set 2 Mix 95 F.rx2 | 10.19 MB | ||
| Loop Set 2a 95 bpm F Intro | |||
| 02a Electric Piano 1 95 F.rx2 | 577.68 KB | ||
| 02a Electric Piano 2 95 F.rx2 | 519.37 KB | ||
| 02a Hat 95.rx2 | 176.76 KB | ||
| 02a Kick 95.rx2 | 76.06 KB | ||
| 02a Snare 95.rx2 | 207.42 KB | ||
| Loop Set 2b 95 bpm F Chorus | |||
| 02b Bass 95 F.rx2 | 1.19 MB | ||
| 02b Electric Piano 1 95 F.rx2 | 2.61 MB | ||
| 02b Electric Piano 2 95 F.rx2 | 2.4 MB | ||
| 02b Hat 95.rx2 | 1.47 MB | ||
| 02b Kick 95.rx2 | 383.82 KB | ||
| 02b Pipes 95 F.rx2 | 2.63 MB | ||
| 02b Snap 1 95.rx2 | 217.53 KB | ||
| 02b Snap 2 95.rx2 | 286.6 KB | ||
| 02b Snare 95.rx2 | 1.2 MB | ||
| 02b Synth 95 F.rx2 | 2.67 MB | ||
| Loop Set 2c 95 bpm F Verse | |||
| 02c Bass 95 F.rx2 | 1.18 MB | ||
| 02c Electric Piano 1 95 F.rx2 | 2.51 MB | ||
| 02c Electric Piano 2 95 F.rx2 | 2.45 MB | ||
| 02c Hat 95.rx2 | 1.47 MB | ||
| 02c Kick 95.rx2 | 399.98 KB | ||
| 02c Snap 1 95.rx2 | 429.53 KB | ||
| 02c Snap 2 95.rx2 | 573.3 KB | ||
| 02c Snare 95.rx2 | 1.2 MB | ||
| Loop Set 3 93 bpm A | |||
| 03 Clap 93.rx2 | 353.15 KB | ||
| 03 Conga 93.rx2 | 633.83 KB | ||
| 03 Kick 93.rx2 | 967.56 KB | ||
| 03 Organ 93 A.rx2 | 1.12 MB | ||
| 03 Ride 93.rx2 | 2.41 MB | ||
| 03 Shaker 93.rx2 | 468.46 KB | ||
| 03 Sub 93 A.rx2 | 779.75 KB | ||
| 03 Sweep 93.rx2 | 2.08 MB | ||
| 03 Vocal 1 93.rx2 | 539.26 KB | ||
| Loop Set 3 Mix 93 A.rx2 | 15.77 MB | ||
| Loop Set 4 Mix 90 Bb.rx2 | 12.83 MB | ||
| Loop Set 4a 90 bpm Bb | |||
| 04a Bass 90 Bb.rx2 | 1.39 MB | ||
| 04a Hat 90.rx2 | 601.03 KB | ||
| 04a Kick 90.rx2 | 926.01 KB | ||
| 04a Pizzicado 90 Bb.rx2 | 765.66 KB | ||
| 04a Rhodes 90 Bb.rx2 | 3.35 MB | ||
| 04a Snare 1 90.rx2 | 865.58 KB | ||
| 04a Snare 2 90.rx2 | 139.32 KB | ||
| 04a Strings 90 Bb.rx2 | 2.46 MB | ||
| Loop Set 5 Mix 85 Abm.rx2 | 16.71 MB | ||
| Loop Set 5a 85 bpm Abm Intro | |||
| 05a Guitar 85 Abm.rx2 | 592.54 KB | ||
| 05a Guitar Pluck 85 Abm.rx2 | 122.64 KB | ||
| 05a Hatter 85 Abm.rx2 | 689.44 KB | ||
| 05a Kick 1 85.rx2 | 148.37 KB | ||
| 05a Kick 2 85.rx2 | 110.06 KB | ||
| 05a Snare 1 85.rx2 | 223.34 KB | ||
| 05a Snare 2 85.rx2 | 115.66 KB | ||
| Loop Set 5b 85 bpm Abm Main | |||
| 05a Bass Buzz 85 Abm.rx2 | 729.04 KB | ||
| 05a Electric Piano 85 Abm.rx2 | 3.83 MB | ||
| 05a Guitar 85 Abm.rx2 | 1.9 MB | ||
| 05a Guitar Pluck 85 Abm.rx2 | 386.99 KB | ||
| 05a Hat 85.rx2 | 448.18 KB | ||
| 05a Hatter 85.rx2 | 3.92 MB | ||
| 05a Kick 1 85.rx2 | 166.02 KB | ||
| 05a Kick 2 85.rx2 | 588.43 KB | ||
| 05a Rhodes 85 Abm.rx2 | 3.33 MB | ||
| 05a Snare 1 85.rx2 | 575.17 KB | ||
| 05a Snare 2 85.rx2 | 287.47 KB | ||
| Loop Set 6 86 bpm C | |||
| 06 Bass 86 C.rx2 | 426.75 KB | ||
| 06 FX 86.rx2 | 209.99 KB | ||
| 06 Hat 86.rx2 | 1.14 MB | ||
| 06 Kick 86.rx2 | 753.76 KB | ||
| 06 Pad 86 C.rx2 | 3.07 MB | ||
| 06 Rhodes 1 86 C.rx2 | 2.77 MB | ||
| 06 Rhodes 2 86 C.rx2 | 3.03 MB | ||
| 06 Snare 86.rx2 | 947.23 KB | ||
| 06 Snare Back 86.rx2 | 342.14 KB | ||
| Loop Set 6 Mix 86 C.rx2 | 15.02 MB | ||
| Loop Set 7 96 bpm Cm | |||
| 07 Bass 96 Cm.rx2 | 1.08 MB | ||
| 07 Clap 96.rx2 | 476.52 KB | ||
| 07 Flute 96 Cm.rx2 | 490.47 KB | ||
| 07 Hat 96.rx2 | 402.77 KB | ||
| 07 Kick 1 96.rx2 | 652.15 KB | ||
| 07 Kick 2 96.rx2 | 247.08 KB | ||
| 07 Rhodes 96 Cm.rx2 | 1.49 MB | ||
| 07 Snare 1 96.rx2 | 608.37 KB | ||
| 07 Snare 2 96.rx2 | 769.01 KB | ||
| 07 Strings 96 Cm.rx2 | 3.69 MB | ||
| Loop Set 7 Mix 96 Cm.rx2 | 6.19 MB | ||
| Loop Set 8 95bpm Cm | |||
| 08 Bass 95 Cm.rx2 | 1.27 MB | ||
| 08 Chorus Rhodes 95 Cm.rx2 | 2.54 MB | ||
| 08 Clap 95.rx2 | 1.23 MB | ||
| 08 Drummer 95.rx2 | 1.43 MB | ||
| 08 Hat 95.rx2 | 801.75 KB | ||
| 08 Kick 95.rx2 | 207.67 KB | ||
| 08 Piano 95 Cm.rx2 | 1.43 MB | ||
| 08 Rhodes 95 Cm.rx2 | 2.48 MB | ||
| 08 Rim 95.rx2 | 369.2 KB | ||
| 08 Snap 95.rx2 | 1.22 MB | ||
| Loop Set 8 Mix 95 Cm.rx2 | 6.12 MB | ||
| Loop Set 9 Mix 93 Bbm.rx2 | 8.39 MB | ||
| Loop Set 9a 93 bpm Bbm Intro | |||
| 09a Scratch 93.rx2 | 95.38 KB | ||
| 09a Voices 93 Bbm.rx2 | 708.71 KB | ||
| Loop Set 9b 93 bpm Bbm Main | |||
| 09b Bass 93 Bbm.rx2 | 1.26 MB | ||
| 09b Glide 93 Bbm.rx2 | 358.4 KB | ||
| 09b Hat Single Hit 93 Bbm.rx2 | 552.66 KB | ||
| 09b Hat Triplet 93.rx2 | 1000.65 KB | ||
| 09b Keys 93 Bbm.rx2 | 1.47 MB | ||
| 09b Kick 93.rx2 | 1.29 MB | ||
| 09b Shake 93.rx2 | 792.37 KB | ||
| 09b Snap 93.rx2 | 699.5 KB | ||
| 09b Snare 93.rx2 | 657.99 KB | ||
| 09b Strings 93 Bbm.rx2 | 1.97 MB | ||
| 09b Voices 93 Bbm.rx2 | 3.86 MB | ||
| Vinyl Dilla Loop Sets README.pdf | 266.89 KB |
Программы и Дизайн » Материалы для мультимедиа и дизайна » Библиотеки сэмплов
P5audio - Vinyl Dilla Hip Hop Loop Sets
Издатель: P5Audio
[hr]
Сайт: www.p5audio.com
[hr]
Формат: WAV, REX2
Качество: 24 bit | 44.1 kHz | stereo
[hr]
Описание: Вдохновленный легендарным производителей, таких как Алхимик, J Dilla, хаос и др., этот цикл set pack обеспечивает твердый винил вдохновил петли, идеально подходит для вашего истинного Хип-Хоп производства. С 17 multi-track loop устанавливает организованы в 10 песня наборы, эти 114 отдельные циклы включают в живых инструментов, отобранных и нарезанный прямо с винила.
[spoiler="Содержание"]
- 17 vinyl inspired loop sets arranged into 10 song sets, complete with verse, hook and intro ideas.
- Instrumentation includes deep layered live keyboards, bass, drums, guitar, VOX FX, synths, strings and more.
- 114 individual loops total.
[/spoiler]
[spoiler="Дополнительная информация"]
Inspired by legendary producers such as Alchemist, J Dilla, Havoc and others, this loop set pack delivers gritty vinyl inspired loops, perfect for your true Hip Hop production. Featuring 17 multi-track loop sets arranged into 10 song sets, these 114 individual loops include live instruments sampled and chopped straight from vinyl. Bring authentic grit to your production. Download these loops today!
[/spoiler]
| torrent name | size | uploader | age | seed | leech |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 133.07 MB | yurcheloo2008 | 15 years | 5 | 0 |
All Comments